McKenzie Westmore Host Ve Neill Judge Glenn Hetrick Judge Neville Page Judge Michael Westmore Self Alam Park Contestant Alexandra McCoy Contestant Autumn Cook Contestant David "House" Greathouse Contestant Eric Fox Contestant Eric Zapata Contestant J. Anthony Kosar Contestant Jenna Green Contestant Katherine "Katie" Machiek Contestant Kristian Kobzina Contestant Meagan Hester Contestant Michael Garcia Contestant Troy Rivers Contestant Wayne Anderson Contestant Bryan Singer Guest Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer Derek Atherton Executive Producer