McKenzie Westmore Host Glenn Hetrick Judge Neville Page Judge Ve Neill Judge Michael Westmore Self Ben Ploughman Contestant Brittany Leslie Contestant Evan Hedges Contestant Jasmine Ringo Contestant Jason Henricks Contestant Jordan Patton Contestant Kevon Ward Contestant Libby Rose Goldberg Contestant Megan Wilbur Contestant Melissa "Missy Munster" Stell Contestant Omar Sfreddo Contestant Ricky Vitus Contestant Scott Fensterer Contestant Sidney Cumbie Contestant Stevie Calabrese Contestant Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer Derek Atherton Executive Producer