Donal Logue Sean Finnerty Actor Megyn Price Claudia Finnerty Actor Kevin Corrigan Eddie Finnerty Actor Lynsey Bartilson Lily Finnerty Actor Griffin Frazen Jimmy Finnerty Actor Bret Harrison Brad O'Keefe Actor Miriam Flynn Sister Helen Guest Star Arielle Kebbel Taya Guest Star Karri Bowman Faye Guest Star Ryan Devlin Mocha Joey Guest Star Brandon Lange Moderator Guest Star Emma Gould Young Lily Guest Star Gina St. John Saleslady Guest Star Peter James Smith Dr. Perry Guest Star Allan Trautman Professor Gollin Guest Star Dave Allen Therapist Guest Star Angela Shelton Woman Guest Star Dana Decker Bassist Guest Star Shira Scott Astrof Girl Guest Star Frank Alvarez Man Guest Star John Blanchard Director Keith Truesdell Director Jim Armogida Writer Kristin Holloway Writer Jeff Astrof Writer Chris Kelly Writer Bill Martin Writer Ned Goldreyer Writer Dave Tennant Writer Erica Rivinoja Writer Steve Armogida Writer Rebecca Hughes Writer Mike Sikowitz Writer Mike Schiff Writer Sean Lambert Director