Christopher Cantwell Creator Christopher C. Rogers Creator Lee Pace Joe MacMillan Actor Scoot McNairy Gordon Clark Actor Mackenzie Davis Cameron Howe Actor Kerry Bishé Donna Clark Actor Toby Huss John Bosworth Actor Scott Michael Foster Hunt Whitmarsh Guest Star Will Greenberg Brian Braswell Guest Star Lou Taylor Pucci Heath Guest Star Lenny Jacobson Donnie Manning Guest Star Barak Hardley Petey Manning Guest Star David de Vries Dennis Cummings Guest Star Griff Furst Wally Turner Guest Star Rafiq Batcha Darren Guest Star Neko Parham Nick Rallo Guest Star Robin Bloodworth Bryon Nayhead Guest Star Mike Stoudt Demo Audience Member 1 Guest Star Jonathan Lisco Executive Producer Mark Johnson Executive Producer Melissa Bernstein Executive Producer