Christopher Cantwell Creator Christopher C. Rogers Creator Lee Pace Joe MacMillan Actor Scoot McNairy Gordon Clark Actor Mackenzie Davis Cameron Howe Actor Kerry Bishé Donna Clark Actor Toby Huss John Bosworth Actor Annabeth Gish Actor Manish Dayal Actor Matthew Lillard Ken Diebold Guest Star August Emerson Malcolm Levitan Guest Star Joe Dinicol Craig Bosch Guest Star Jay Huguley Cal Erickson Guest Star Joe Massingill Doug Sheridan Guest Star Cooper Andrews Yo-Yo Engberk Guest Star Joshua Hoover Bodie Guest Star Nick Pupo Carl Guest Star J. Elijah Cho Wonderboy Guest Star Gabriel Manak Arki Guest Star Catherine Dyer Kelly Guest Star Joshua Brady Robot Guest Star Jona Xiao Julie Yang Guest Star Tommas Oden Louis Guest Star Elizabeth Ludlow Cavale Guest Star J. Thomas Bailey Blue Guy 1 Guest Star Frank Corcoran Ben Gould Guest Star Jonathan Lisco Executive Producer Mark Johnson Executive Producer Melissa Bernstein Executive Producer