Michael Waldron Creator, Executive Producer Stephen Amell Jack Spade Actor Alexander Ludwig Ace Spade Actor Alison Luff Staci Spade Actor Mary McCormack Willie Day Actor Kelli Berglund Crystal Actor James Harrison Jr. Apocalypse Actor Robby Ramos Diego Cottonmouth Actor Alice Barrett Carol Spade Actor Roxton Garcia Thomas Spade Actor David James Elliott Tom Spade Actor Joel Murray Actor Spencer Garrett Pastor Heery Actor Melissa LeEllen Actor Duke Davis Roberts Big Jim Kitchen Actor Nigel Crocker Wild Card McGee Actor Larry Clarke Ted Day Actor Zoe Myers Diane Tracey Actor Chris Donnelly Executive Producer Mike O'Malley Executive Producer Patrick Walmsley Executive Producer Julie Yorn Executive Producer