Andrea Savage Andrea Actor Tom Everett Scott Mike Actor Olive Petrucci Amelia Actor Martin Mull Guest Star Jason Mantzoukas Guest Star Gary Anthony Williams Guest Star Peter Breitmayer Guest Star David Carzell Guest Star Mary Grill Guest Star Barry Livingston Guest Star Hiram A. Murray Guest Star Kevin Kirkpatrick Guest Star Jan Broberg Guest Star Judilin Bosita Guest Star Julie Mitchell Guest Star Karole Foreman Guest Star Peggy Dunne Guest Star Danya LaBelle Guest Star