Nathalie Frederick Older Lisa Actor Lori Bodinizzo Actor Paige Felger Young Jemima Actor Ilir Fiora Sorek Minery , Male Cultist Actor Nancy Marlowe Gordon Angela Smith Actor Elana Valastro Young Karen Actor Greg Henry Executive Producer Kim Woodard Executive Producer Isaac Holub Executive Producer Michael Sheridan Executive Producer Jess Cagle Executive Producer Dan Wakeford Executive Producer Dahlia Damaghi Supervising Producer