Cedric Yarbrough Deputy S. Jones Actor Niecy Nash Deputy Raineesha Williams Actor Robert Ben Garant Deputy Travis Junior Actor, Producer, Executive Producer, Writer, Director Thomas Lennon Lt. Jim Dangle Actor, Director, Executive Producer Carlos Alazraqui Deputy James Garcia Actor Wendi McLendon-Covey Deputy Clementine Johnson Actor Kerri Kenney Deputy Trudy Wiegel Actor, Executive Producer, Writer Mary Birdsong Deputy Cherisha Kimball Actor Keegan-Michael Key Theoretical Criminal Guest Star Jack Plotnick Steve Marmella Guest Star Steve Hart Park Ranger Guest Star Toby Huss Big Mike Guest Star Nick Swardson Terry Bernadino Guest Star Lisa Lampanelli Reverend Goldberg Guest Star Gary Anthony Williams Enrique Dangle Guest Star Norma Mora Rodriguez Brother Guest Star Jenn Shagrin High School Girl Guest Star Jim Rash Andrew Guest Star La Na Shi Girl Scout Guest Star Nadine Ellis Guest Star Danny DeVito Executive Producer John Landgraf Executive Producer Michael Shamberg Executive Producer Stacey Sher Executive Producer Peter Principato Executive Producer Paul Young Executive Producer