Nell Scovell Creator, Executive Producer, Writer Melissa Joan Hart Sabrina Spellman Actor Caroline Rhea Hilda Spellman Actor Beth Broderick Zelda Spellman Actor Nate Richert Harvey Kinkle Actor Michelle Beaudoin Jennifer 'Jenny' Kelley Actor Jenna Leigh Green Libby Chessler Actor Paul Feig Mr. Eugene Pool Actor Nick Bakay Actor Penn Jillette Drell Guest Star Teller Skippy Guest Star Debbie Harry Cassandra Guest Star Robby Benson Edward Spellman Guest Star, Director Melissa Murray-Mutch Guest Star Bridget Flanery Jill Guest Star Renn Woods Mrs. Hecht Guest Star Shaun Weiss Male Student Guest Star Paula Hart Executive Producer