Tim McAuliffe Creator, Executive Producer Mark Critch Mike Critch Creator, Actor, Executive Producer Benjamin Evan Ainsworth Mark Critch Actor Malcolm McDowell Patrick Critch Actor Claire Rankin Mary Critch Actor Mark Ezekiel Rivera Ritchie Perez Actor Sophia Powers Fox Actor Colton Gobbo Mike Critch Jr. Actor Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll Father Garcia Guest Star Allan Hawco Executive Producer Andrew Barnsley Executive Producer Renuka Jeyapalan Executive Producer, Director Ben Murray Executive Producer Perry Chafe Writer