Alexi Hawley Creator Nathan Fillion John Nolan Actor, Executive Producer Shawn Ashmore Wesley Evers Actor Deric Augustine Miles Penn Actor Lisseth Chavez Celina Juarez Actor Mekia Cox Nyla Harper Actor Alyssa Diaz Angela Lopez Actor Richard T. Jones Sergeant Wade Grey Actor Titus Makin Jr. Jackson West Actor Melissa O'Neil Lucy Chen Actor Eric Winter Tim Bradford, Tim Bradford Actor, Guest Star Jenna Dewan Bailey Nune Guest Star Anna Garcia Self Vic Michaelis Self Zac Oyama Self Sam Reich Self Jacob Wysocki Jacob Wysocki Self Angel Parker Luna Grey Guest Star Arjay Smith James Murray Guest Star Beckett Hawley Dash Guest Star Tyler Ritter Mark Wyatt Guest Star Freda Foh Shen Maeve Guest Star Brianne Tju Finley Guest Star Joe Daru Jasper Waterson Guest Star Charles Michael Davis Dr. Oliver Ashton Guest Star Jan M. Janssen Officer Jan Guest Star Cole Gleason Suspect One Guest Star Eilise Patton Poppy Waterson Guest Star Juliette Myers EMT Guest Star Mark Gordon Executive Producer Michelle Chapman Executive Producer Jon Steinberg Executive Producer Terence Paul Winter Executive Producer Rob Bowman Executive Producer Bill Norcross Executive Producer Stephanie Martin Director Madeleine Coghlan Writer Fatima Eldigair Screenwriter Chelsea Urech Screenwriter Jordan Gagne Music Kyle Jewell Cinematographer Alexander Aquino-Kaljakin Film Editor Eric Dawson Casting Carol Kritzer Casting Rory Schleifstein Casting Robert J. Ulrich Casting