James Drury The Virginian Actor Doug McClure Trampas Actor Lee J. Cobb Judge Henry Garth Actor John McIntire Clay Grainger Guest Star Charles Bronson Harge Talbot Guest Star Sara Lane Elizabeth Grainger Guest Star Kiel Martin Tony Barnes Guest Star Steve Carlson Willy Jackson Guest Star Susan Oliver Ellen Cooper Guest Star Woodrow Parfrey Hobie Simpson Guest Star Joanna Moore Carol Fisk Guest Star Jeanette Nolan Holly Grainger Guest Star Ross Elliott Sheriff Mark Abbott Guest Star Tom Bell Cpl. Johnny Moon Guest Star Ann Doran Mrs. Graves Guest Star J. Pat O'Malley Joe Keller Guest Star Ben Johnson Joe Hogan Guest Star Henry Beckman Corey Guest Star Russell Thorson Judge Craig Guest Star Jill Donohue Lucy Evers Guest Star Norman MacDonnell Executive Producer John Dunkel Writer Stanford Whitmore Writer Sy Salkowitz Writer True Boardman Writer Andy Lewis Writer Don Tait Writer Judith Barrows Writer Edward J. Lakso Writer Norman Katkov Writer Douglas Morrow Writer Barbara Merlin Writer Don McDougall Director Abner Biberman Director Leonard Praskins Writer Joel Rogosin Director Leo Penn Director Robert L. Friend Director Robert Guy Barrows Writer Charles S. Dubin Director