Lily Rabe Claire Bennigan Actor Barry Sloane Wes Lawrence Actor Milo Ventimiglia John Doe Actor Derek Webster Jessup Rollins Actor Kristen Connolly Lena Larence Actor Kylie Rogers Minx Lawrence Actor Kyle Breitkopf Henry Bennigan Actor Abby Ryder Fortson Guest Star Alan Ruck Guest Star David Andrews Guest Star Gwynyth Walsh Guest Star Jamison Jones Guest Star Catherine Lough Haggquist Guest Star Ken Tremblett Guest Star Loretta Walsh Guest Star Arien Boey Guest Star Maeve Dudley Guest Star Ona Grauer Guest Star Terrell Ransom Jr. Guest Star Jessie Fraser Guest Star Olivia Dewhurst Guest Star Daryl King Guest Star Chantele Francis Guest Star Curtis Lum Guest Star Romuald Hivert Guest Star Steven Spielberg Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Dawn Parouse Executive Producer Alison Tatlock Writer P.J. Pesce Director