Episode 1
Aired Oct 9, 1959
Red Terror of Tombstone
RC Tuttle starts a campaign to encourage residents to move to Benson because of Tombstone's low water supply and inadequate fire fighting equipment, leading a merchant to set fire to his own store to frame Tuttle.
Details
Episode 2
Aired Oct 16, 1959
To the Last Man
A rancher hires a gunfighter to protect him from Jeff Harper, the last member of a family that has waged a feud with the rancher; Harper says he wants a truce with the rancher, but the hired gunfighter's trigger finger itches.
Details
Episode 3
Aired Oct 23, 1959
The Hidden Gunman
Sheriff Hollister arrests pretty Anita Torreon as a receiver of loot for a holdup gang and takes her to Prescott to stand trial; aboard the stagecoach, a disguised gunman suddenly appears to rescue Anita and recover the loot.
Details
Episode 4
Aired Oct 30, 1959
The Writer
Beautiful Elizabeth Blythe comes from New York to Tombstone to write a story about the town too tough to die; her nose for news promptly leads her into mortal danger when she is captured by outlaw Ed Chandler.
Details
Episode 5
Aired Nov 6, 1959
The Man from Yuma
Released from prison together, Jake Conroy and Hobe Jones scheme to rob a rich mine owner; with the cash in their control, the thieves ride hard from Mexico with Sheriff Clay Hollister and Editor Harris Claibourne in pursuit.
Details
Episode 6
Aired Nov 13, 1959
The Horse Thief
Hollister stops gunman Jess Buckhorn from shooting Little Hawk, who denies stealing horses from a mission; attorney Fred Griffin, the gunman's secret employer, is plotting to discredit the Indians so he can gain title to their land.
Details
Episode 7
Aired Nov 20, 1959
The Legend
Writer Jay Pell sets out to create a new legendary bad man for his readers; he persuades an outlaw to hold up a stagecoach so that he can write an eyewitness account; when things go wrong, Sheriff Clay Hollister is tricked into another scheme.
Details
Episode 8
Aired Nov 27, 1959
Ten Feet Tall
With his fiancée arriving from London, Ron Browning will do anything to keep her from finding out what a failure he is, even die, at least on paper; his courage in a later crisis may restore his self respect and save the sheriff at the same time.
Details
Episode 9
Aired Dec 4, 1959
Dangerous Romance
Paul Hayden is baited into a fight with three wild brothers, wounding one; when he later meets and falls in love with Karen Thomas, the sister of his three assailants, Hollister attempts to untangle the snarled affairs and prevent murder.
Details
Episode 10
Aired Dec 11, 1959
The Price on Clay's Head
In self defense, Sheriff Hollister gunned down the son of the richest rancher in the territory, who offers a $10,000 reward for Clay's death; a Marshal of a neighboring town lures the sheriff out so he, himself, can kill Clay and claim the reward.
Details
Episode 11
Aired Dec 18, 1959
For Want of a Nail
A wealthy rancher is killed and robbed of the ranch payroll; with only a horseshoe print to go by, Sheriff Hollister and Editor Claibourne set about trapping the culprit and end up meeting him in a furious fight.
Details
Episode 12
Aired Dec 25, 1959
The Hanging
The rope used to hang Reed Barker breaks, and he survives, absolving him of all of his crimes; Clay Hollister investigates how the rope broke.
Details
Episode 13
Aired Jan 1, 1960
Death Writes a Headline
Angered over several recent mine disasters, Sheriff Hollister wages a campaign for mine safety legislation with the aid of Editor Claibourne of the Tombstone Epitaph; in the process, they uncover a clever ruse to discredit the safety campaign.
Details
Episode 14
Aired Jan 8, 1960
The Witness
Adam Kirby witnesses a murder in the livery stable; then makes the mistake of shooting off his mouth about it, leading to the killer coming after him; Sheriff Hollister baits a trap with Kirby and waits to trap the killer and save Kirby.
Details
Episode 15
Aired Jan 15, 1960
The Capture
When a U.S. Marshal is ambushed while bringing in outlaw Kyle Dodge, he turns his captive over to Sheriff Hollister just before he dies, with the cryptic warning to trust nobody; forewarned, the Sheriff forestalls a clever attempt to free Dodge.
Details
Episode 16
Aired Jan 22, 1960
A Funeral for Chalky
In order to trap an outlaw gang, the Epitaph reports that a gang member is turning state's witness; the outlaw dies of his wounds, but his death is kept secret; in a bold move, the gang kidnaps Claibourne and offers to exchange him for the outlaw.
Details
Episode 17
Aired Jan 29, 1960
The Trap
Claibourne witnesses Vic Reel kill a newspaperman from Denver; in his efforts to uncover the motive for the murder, Hollister succeeds in the capture of the Taylor gang.
Details
Episode 18
Aired Feb 5, 1960
The Bride
Rancher Bert Magraw returns from Denver with his young bride Jeannie; the same day, notorious gunslinger Vince Sanders arrives in town and baits Magraw into a gunfight; Sheriff Hollister steps in to save Magraw's life and uncover a conspiracy.
Details
Episode 19
Aired Feb 12, 1960
Prisoner to Yuma
Convicted of slugging and robbing a miner, Renee Carter is being taken to Yuma prison; when the miner dies, she must return for trial, but Hollister believes she is covering up for a gambler, Frank Fallon, who will try to prevent her return.
Details
Episode 20
Aired Feb 19, 1960
Frozen Assets
Sheriff Clay Hollister sends for a woman lawyer to settle a dispute between a mine owner and a local businessman; Clay is unaware that one of the men has been stealing gold and putting it in blocks of ice.
Details
Episode 21
Aired Feb 26, 1960
Lady Killer
Hollister investigates a series of mysterious deaths among the silver miners and links Lily Murdock, the town's most respected woman, with the tragedies; Lily is so well liked by the townspeople that the sheriff dares not accuse her openly.
Details
Episode 22
Aired Mar 4, 1960
The Big Gun
Marshal Vern Fawcett resigns after killing one of the Holcomb brothers and returns to Tombstone to be with his family and to marry his girlfriend.
Details
Episode 23
Aired Mar 11, 1960
Young Killer
Hollister rushes a young wounded hoodlum to Tombstone's hospital, putting him under the care of nurse Mary Rice; when the notorious Gayleyville gang kidnaps her and the dying boy, Hollister and the wounded man each attempt to save the nurse.
Details
Episode 24
Aired Mar 18, 1960
Coded Newspaper
Fragment of the Epitaph's are found at the scene of a robbery and on the body of a known killer; Hollister and Claibourne discover a strange code in the help wanted ads and with a planned typographic error; they smoke out a robbery gang.
Details
Episode 25
Aired Mar 25, 1960
Memory
Liz Dolthan persuades Sam Wade to place her jewelry overnight in the Wells Fargo safe, and remembers the combination as she watches him open it; Hollister's sharp mind and keen observations help him solve the subsequent $20,000 theft.
Details
Episode 26
Aired Apr 1, 1960
Revenge
Jonas Bell is killed in a scuffle with Hollister after a bank clerk is murdered; siblings Noah and Lady Bell conspire to avenge their father targeting Hollister.
Details
Episode 27
Aired Apr 8, 1960
Escape From Hanging
Murderer Sam Edwards has been sentenced to hang, but his brother, John, kidnaps Harris and takes him hostage to save Sam from the gallows.
Details
Episode 28
Aired Apr 16, 1960
The Governor
Hollister risks his life to rescue the governor, who has been kidnapped by a gang.
Details
Episode 29
Aired Apr 22, 1960
The Kidnapping
Hope Jensen turns in a bag of stolen money that her husband had been forced to hide in their barn by Ben Jensen and his gang.
Details
Episode 30
Aired Apr 22, 1960
Poison Town
Belle Reed's sister poses as her, with hopes of trapping her killer.
Details
Episode 31
Aired May 6, 1960
Low Card Kills
Hollister is captured by three escaped convicts who are trying to decide which one will kill him.
Details
Episode 32
Aired May 13, 1960
The Innocent Man
Hollister is given new evidence that points to the innocence of an escaped convict.
Details
Episode 33
Aired May 20, 1960
The Siesta Killer
An insurance investigator assists Hollister in finding the Siesta Killer.
Details
Episode 34
Aired May 27, 1960
Killer At Large
Clay tries to clear Kansas Joe Barton of threatening to kill Territorial Gov. Armstrong.
Details
Episode 35
Aired Jun 3, 1960
Betrayal
Hollister captures a wounded bank robber in the desert after he kills both of their horses.
Details
Episode 36
Aired Jun 10, 1960
The Treaty
Hollister uses a specially equipped stagecoach to trap Manatou after he attacks innocents.
Details
Episode 37
Aired Jun 17, 1960
Wanted by the Epitaph
The Epitaph's editor, Claibourne, follows up on a report that a notorious outlaw is living in Tombstone as a respected citizen; Hollister gets clues from a strange poker result and a spur taken in a mugging; two residents become the prime suspects.
Details
Episode 38
Aired Jun 24, 1960
The Injury
Ed Keel is out for revenge on an injured Hollister after the the hanging of his brother.
Details
Episode 39
Aired Jul 1, 1960
Crime Epidemic
The Burnett brothers take refuge in a couple's barn cellar following a bank robbery.
Details
Episode 40
Aired Jul 8, 1960
Calculated Risk
Hollister poses as a jailed man to stop a man from attacking Tombstone.
Details