Jamie Bell Abraham Woodhull Actor Seth Numrich Ben Tallmadge Actor Daniel Henshall Caleb Brewster Actor Heather Lind Anna Strong Actor Meegan Warner Mary Woodhull Actor Kevin R. McNally Judge Richard Woodhull Actor Burn Gorman Maj. Edmund Hewlett Actor Angus Macfadyen Robert Rogers Actor Samuel Roukin Lt. John Simcoe Actor JJ Feild Maj. John Andre Actor Jonathan Coyne Col. Jonathan Cooke Guest Star Aldis Hodge Jordan Guest Star Idara Victor Abigail Guest Star Robert Beitzel Selah Strong Guest Star Jamie Harris Will Robeson Guest Star Amy Gumenick Philomena Guest Star John Curran Daniel Weir Guest Star Lowrey Brown Capt. Blake Guest Star Arthur Bridgers Capt. Henry Guest Star Eamon Sylvias Hyland Lieutenant Guest Star Greg Cooper Warden Guest Star Estes Tarver Captain Guest Star David Lee Nelson Officer No. 1 Guest Star Keith Flippen Officer No. 2 Guest Star Tavis L. Baker Redcoat Guard Guest Star Ken Arnold Merchant Guest Star Ramsey Hanchette Dinner Guest Guest Star Thor Macht Civilian, Continental Soldier, Tory Guest Star Andrew McKeough John Carter Guest Star Scott Mielock British Officer Guest Star James Nevins Merchant Guest Star John Newberry Continental Soldier Guest Star Darby O'Donnell Redcoat Officer Guest Star Brian Schools Continental Officer Guest Star Christopher Henry Stephens Continental Officer Guest Star Dietrich Teschner Militiaman Guest Star John T. Witt Prisoner, Core Villager Guest Star Jeremy Webb Director LaToya Morgan Writer