Jamie Bell Abraham Woodhull Actor Seth Numrich Ben Tallmadge Actor Daniel Henshall Caleb Brewster Actor Heather Lind Anna Strong Actor Meegan Warner Mary Woodhull Actor Kevin R. McNally Judge Richard Woodhull Actor Burn Gorman Maj. Hewlett Actor Angus Macfadyen Robert Rogers Actor Samuel Roukin Lt. John Simcoe Actor JJ Feild Maj. John Andre Actor Ian Kahn Gen. George Washington Actor Owain Yeoman Benedict Arnold Actor Ksenia Solo Peggy Shippen Actor Nick Westrate Robert Townsend Actor Mark Rolston Judge Edward Shippen Guest Star Reg Rogers Randall Guest Star Idara Victor Abigail Guest Star Ric Reitz Rev. Worthington Guest Star Darren Alford Cicero Guest Star Aaron Angus Militia Guest Star Nick Basta Cpl. Eastin Guest Star John Bostic Hiram Dearborn Guest Star Cabell Chase Thomas Guest Star Ellis Chase Thomas Guest Star Mitch Eakins Maj. William Bradford Guest Star Aidan Fiske Philly Boy No. 3 Guest Star James K. Flynn Fulton Crane Guest Star Billy 4 Johnston Philly Boy Guest Star Alexis Leggett Townsperson Guest Star Benjamin Loeh Tory Militia Captain Guest Star Andrew McKeough John Carter Guest Star Michael Raver Red Coat Guest Star Ashley Smith Capt. Wakefield Guest Star Dietrich Teschner Thomas Hickey Guest Star Keith Tyree Provost Marshal Guest Star Xavier Wolf Philly Boy No. 2 Guest Star Timothy Brooks Continental Militia Guest Star Brandon Driver Queens Ranger Guest Star Sean Haggerty Alexander Hamilton Guest Star Kellen Landis Continental Soldier Guest Star Dakota James Alden Lane Militia Guest Star Reese Langlois Townsperson Guest Star Derek Turner Redcoat Officer Guest Star Craig Silverstein Executive Producer, Writer Barry Josephson Executive Producer Michael Taylor Co-Executive Producer Michael Nankin Director