Jamie Bell Abraham Woodhull Actor Seth Numrich Ben Tallmadge Actor Daniel Henshall Caleb Brewster Actor Heather Lind Anna Strong Actor Meegan Warner Mary Woodhull Actor Samuel Roukin Lt. John Simcoe Actor Kevin R. McNally Judge Richard Woodhull Actor Ksenia Solo Peggy Shippen Actor Ian Kahn Gen. George Washington Actor Owain Yeoman Benedict Arnold Actor Nick Westrate Robert Townsend Actor Kelly AuCoin Hercules Mulligan Guest Star Tina Benko Mrs. Barnes Guest Star Jonathan Coyne Col. Jonathan Cooke Guest Star Lilli Birdsell Martha Guest Star David Furr Walter Havens Guest Star Edward Akrout Amos Parker Guest Star Jesse C. Boyd Falkoff Guest Star Sean Haggerty Alexander Hamilton Guest Star Dalton Harrod Blaylock Guest Star Benjamin Keepers Robert Beddows Guest Star Nick McCallum Corporal Guest Star Timothy McKinney Jebediah Carney Guest Star Laura Meakin Hesther Carney Guest Star Sasha Morfaw Zipporah Guest Star Justin Mortelliti Spelling Guest Star Karina Ortiz Sofia Guest Star RJ Shearer Dragoon Guest Star Ashley Smith Capt. Wakefield Guest Star Mark Allan Stewart Teddy Beddows Guest Star Aaron Angus Dragoon Guest Star John Dever Ragged Boozer Guest Star Matt Gulbranson Jailer Guest Star James A. Howard Tory in Tavern Guest Star Darby O'Donnell Redcoat Officer Guest Star Craig Silverstein Executive Producer Barry Josephson Executive Producer Michael Taylor Co-Executive Producer, Writer Andrew McCarthy Director