Poppy Montgomery Carrie Wells Actor Dylan Walsh Det. Al Burns Actor Michael Gaston Det. Mike Costello Actor Kevin Rankin Det. Roe Saunders Actor Daya Vaidya Det. Nina Inara Actor Brad Aldous Suit Guest Star Tim Barker Officer Guest Star Robert Clohessy Jack Healy Guest Star Carol Commissiong NYPD Officer Guest Star Daniel Cosgrove Chad Martin Guest Star Chris Critelli Pledge Guest Star Brendan Dooling Frat Boy 2 Guest Star Carl Ducena NYPD Officer Guest Star Jason Dworak Miles Novak Guest Star Omar Evans Flower Delivery Man Guest Star Greg Harvey Barry Tanner Guest Star Barret Helms Jeremy Hall Guest Star Adam Huber Frat Boy 1 Guest Star Tom Lipinski Colin Marsh Guest Star Britt Lower Tanya Sitkowsky Guest Star Chazz Menendez Frank Dorner Guest Star Nicolette Robinson Mena Levy Guest Star Mike Steinmetz Jonas Heller Guest Star Nikki E Walker Paramedic Guest Star Zach Grabowski Pledge Guest Star Danny Lee ESU Officer Guest Star Connor Vilaca Extra Guest Star Ed Redlich Executive Producer John Bellucci Executive Producer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Jim Adler Writer John David Coles Director