Sue Tenney Creator Alexandra Breckenridge Melinda Monroe Actor Martin Henderson Jack Sheridan Actor Tim Matheson Doc Mullins Actor Annette O'Toole Hope McCrea Actor Colin Lawrence John "Preacher" Middleton Actor Benjamin Hollingsworth Dan Brady Actor Zibby Allen Brie Actor Sarah Dugdale Lizzie Actor Mark Ghanimé Dr. Cameron Hayek Actor Kai Bradbury Denny Cutler Actor Kandyse McClure Kaia Actor Marco Grazzini Mike Actor Cody Kearsley Clay Guest Star Austin Nichols Dr. Eli Kelly Guest Star Teryl Rothery Muriel Saint Claire Guest Star John Ralston Roland Guest Star Sara Canning Victoria Guest Star Rachel Drance Marley Thurston Guest Star Clare Filipow Hannah Guest Star Keith MacKechnie Nick Guest Star Matt Afonso Frank Guest Star Marlon Kazadi Cody Guest Star Rahat Saini Hipster Girl Guest Star David Epstein Hipster Guy Guest Star Rochelle Allison Norma Guest Star, Art Director Ian Rozylo Out-of-Towner Guest Star Roma Roth Executive Producer Chris Perry Executive Producer Robyn Carr Executive Producer Jocelyn Freid Executive Producer Amy Palmer Robertson Executive Producer Andy Mikita Director Erin Cardillo Writer Richard Keith Writer Jeff Garber Original Music David Pelletier Cinematographer Nicole Ratcliffe Film Editor Tiffany Mak Casting Tony Devenyi Production Design Judith Feller Costume Design