Paul Rudd Andy Actor Amy Poehler Susie Actor Bradley Cooper Ben Actor Elizabeth Banks Lindsay Actor Janeane Garofalo Beth Actor Michael Ian Black McKinley Actor Nina Hellman Nancy Actor Joe Lo Truglio Neil Actor Ken Marino Victor Kulak Actor Christopher Meloni Gene Actor Marguerite Moreau Katie Actor Zak Orth J.J. Actor David Hyde Pierce Henry Newman Actor Marisa Ryan Abby Bernstein Actor Molly Shannon Gail von Kleinenstein Actor Michael Showalter Alan Shemper Actor, Executive Producer, Writer David Wain Executive Producer, Writer Howard Bernstein Executive Producer Jonathan Stern Executive Producer Peter Principato Executive Producer