Ashley Lyle Creator, Executive Producer, Writer Bart Nickerson Creator, Executive Producer, Writer Melanie Lynskey Shauna Actor Juliette Lewis Natalie Actor Christina Ricci Misty Actor Tawny Cypress Taissa Actor Ella Purnell Jackie Actor Steven Krueger Ben Scott Actor Samantha Hanratty Teen Misty Actor Sophie Thatcher Teen Natalie Actor Sophie Nélisse Teen Shauna Actor Jasmin Savoy Brown Teen Taissa Actor Warren Kole Jeff Sadecki Actor Lauren Ambrose Vanessa Actor Liv Hewson Teen Vanessa Actor Simone Kessell Lottie Actor Courtney Eaton Teen Lottie Actor Kevin Alves Teen Travis Martinez Actor Nicole Maines Lisa Actor Jonathan Lisco Executive Producer Drew Comins Executive Producer Karyn Kusama Executive Producer Sarah L. Thompson Executive Producer Daisy von Scherler Mayer Director