Tim Blake Nelson Bolger Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer Edward Norton Bill Kincaid , Brady Kincaid Actor, Producer Keri Russell Janet Actor Richard Dreyfuss Pug Rothbaum Actor Susan Sarandon Daisy Kincaid Actor Melanie Lynskey Colleen Actor Josh Pais Ken Feinman Actor Ty Burrell Professor Sorenson Actor Maggie Siff Rabbi Zimmerman Actor Lucy DeVito Anne Greenstein Actor Randal Reeder Shaver Actor Krystal Mayo Bacchanalian Actor Steve Earle Buddy Fuller Actor Lee Wilkof Levy Actor Naima Imani Lett Sally Actor Tim Ware Minister Davies Actor Lisa Benavides Suzie Feinman Actor Elie Cohn Producer Bill Migliore Producer John Langley Producer Kristina Dubin Producer Stuart Blumberg Executive Producer Boaz Davidson Executive Producer Danny Dimbort Executive Producer Avi Lerner Executive Producer Trevor Short Executive Producer David Koplan Executive Producer Jeff Danna Original Music Roberto Schaefer Cinematographer Michelle Botticelli Film Editing Avy Kaufman Casting Maria Nay Set Decoration Caroline Eselin Costume Design Max Biscoe Production Design Rob Simons Art Director