Jul 04, 2011
8.3/10
"Big Fan" is so very wrongly advertised as a straight-up comedy. Even the poster features undertones of comedy; it depicts a melancholic Patton Oswalt with sports-fan make-up all over his face. Yes, that is funny; he is miserable and sad. Perhaps this was an attempt at dark comedy, although it certainly got me to watch the film. I started "Big Fan" knowing only the premise and the star. I had not read any reviews prior to my viewing, and maybe this worked for my personal benefit. I conclude that I had no idea what was destined to hit me.
"Big Fan" is an extraordinarily crafty drama that does indeed double as some sort of comedy, although sticks to its dramatic side for most of its 85-minute run time. I suppose this is a good thing, because the script is strong within the genre of drama. I didn't expect it to be as good of a film as it was. Hell, given the subject matter, it gives me no reason why I should have enjoyed or even LIKED the film. But you never can tell, can you?
Paul (Patton Oswalt) is a big fan (of the New York Giants football team). His one and only friend is Sal (Kevin Corrigan), and yes, Sal is also a " big fan", although Paul might be into his passion just a wee bit more. Paul is depicted as a lovable low-life who lives with his mother and works as an attendant in a parking garage. Being a New York Giants fan may be his only reason to live, and his only form of escapism.
Paul spends his "other life", as a fan, quite well. He's a frequent caller for a local sports radio station, where he bashes an opposing rival team, the Philadelphia Eagles. The Eagles also have their own devoted supporter, who locks horns with Paul more than often, on the radio show.
Did I forget to mention that Paul's favorite Giants player is Quantrell Bishop? Yeah, well...he is. One night, Paul and Sal are out on a drive, and they see their favorite football star out in the big city. They follow the guy to a strip club, where they finally confront him, and, well...let's just say that Paul ends up meeting his idol in ways he could have never imagined or wanted.
Paul gets beaten by the man he so closely and gleefully idolized. Afterwards, he refuses to sue. This is because he does not want the Giants to lose their greatest and most influential player. However, Bishop ends up being taken out of play for quite some time anyways, and Paul's team goes to hell afterwards. There is stuff that most definitely happens after the events I have already described, but this film is too good to spoil...at least completely. It is backed by so many things that yes, I would even go as far as to call it fascinating and whimsical.
Yet, the film is also bleak and dark. Very dark. It has laughs, as it is part comedy, but some of them will be tough sells. You might not always laugh out loud at the humorous moments, and you might feel bad for the central character, but none-the-less, this is a film with more humanity than half the films on the market today. It is an indie picture, yes, but hardly one for the hipster crowd. Hell, I'm not even sure if it's for the sport fan crowd. They could probably relate to some of it, but will they truly like it? I cannot say.
Patton Oswalt has proven himself a worthy opponent of ANYONE when it comes to comedy acting, but here he tries his hand at drama, and succeeds almost miraculously. How the script, for this film, was pulled off so ingeniously, I shall never know. It's almost impossible to come across people in the movie business who are intelligent quite like the writers of this film were. They mix satire with the darkness of the human heart. Sometimes I smiled, sometimes I frowned. None the less, I was intoxicated in Oswalt's performance, the script, and just about everything else. This is a film that deserves an audience. Consider me a fan.
Verified