Mary Poppins Returns
Log in with Facebook
Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Sign up here
and the Terms and Policies,
and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango.
Already have an account? Log in here
Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password.
No consensus yet.
No consensus yet.
All Critics (6)
| Top Critics (5)
| Fresh (3)
| Rotten (3)
An intriguing, low-budget look at a young vigilante whose "heroism" comes with much moral ambivalence.
Sometimes I think vigilante dramas would be more tolerable if they were pure violent payback, without all the moral grandstanding about our flawed criminal justice system.
I started watching it with moderate expectations and was surprised by how quickly I was drawn in; the movie works insistently on an emotional level.
Morrissey displays a flair for moody atmospherics as his protagonist wanders Gotham's streets and subways at night, but the film relies too heavily on cryptic flashbacks and deliberate gaps in the narrative to create suspense.
Though the story eventually develops some shading, Mr. Morrissey's enthusiasm for graphic novels is evident in every overstylized frame and underwritten conversation.
... a spectacular debut for director Michael Morrisey... [Full review in Spanish]
I thought this film had a very clever ending, it's such a shame that the rest of the film was so boring and uninteresting. It's clear that this film has a minimal budget, but they make the most they can with it. The problem I have is with the scripting, even though there is some comedic moments, the drama is overly serious to the point where it's laughable. The film also fails to create much suspense, preferring to use flashbacks to the moment of Sean's mom's murder and trying to use mysterious death to help carry the film. It doesn't really work, because it's all fairly predictable stuff to be honest. I did like the fact that the movie chose to present its character with a bit of moral ambiguity because since he's not in his right mind, you're never sure what he's doing or if what he's seeing in actually real. They do this by having, from Sean's point of view, by exaggerating the arguments he sees on the streets. For example, an arguing couple from Sean's view, looks considerably worse than it is, he sees the man yelling angrily at his girlfriend when in reality he's calm. So it's not like you can trust Sean's actions, you don't know if he's doing the right thing or not. The problem with this is that the actor who plays Sean, Caleb Steinmeyer, isn't very good. I suppose he's suppose to sell the fact that the character is an introvert with very obvious emotional problems, but I just found his delivery to be wooden and dull and it's hard to feel any sympathy for the character. And Zulay Henao isn't great either, she wasn't entirely convincing in her role. If anything, Bill Sage as Sean's father is the acting highlight of the film as he's the most interesting character in the entire film as he's the one who has the most to carry emotionally for the way he was with Sean and his mom before her death. I do think the movie has some good atmosphere but the rest of the film is fairly below average. The scripting isn't strong, nor is the story and the acting from the leads is largely terrible. That doesn't make this movie terrible, but it does make it very below average.
Another vigilante movie, yet not. Nice dark twist to this one. This film combines humor, drama, mystery, emotion, a little action, and then throws in an unconventional ending to top things off. Really good independent film...
Cast: James Russo, Zulay Henao, Tracy Middendorf, Bill Sage, John Sharian, Alex Manette, Suzanne Didonna, Caleb Steinmeyer
Director: Michael Morrissey
Summary: Years after witnessing his mother's brutal murder, withdrawn Sean Donovan develops a dark alter ego and starts dispensing some vigilante justice. But soon a dedicated cop picks up his trail, and Sean's twisted crusade begins to implode.
My Thoughts: "This surprisingly turned out to be better then what I was expecting. With a mostly unknown cast of characters, I was expecting bad acting, editing, and story-line. So it was nice to be surprised by how wrong I was. Caleb Steinmeyer, plays dark and brooding Sean Donovan. He did a great job in his role. I will have to look out for him in more roles. The revenge is brutal and swift. Sean becomes this darker alter ego and it is a bit scary how quiet and shy he is at first to then be this lethal force to be reckoned with. The ending was great. I was pleasantly surprised by it as well. Just a great revenge thriller. One I wouldn't mind seeing again."
Much better than I thought it would be. An ensemble cast that clicks, a story that takes a few unanticipated turns, and a director that obviously knows his stuff.
View All Quotes