Dave McCary Director Kyle Mooney James Pope Actor, Screenwriter Greg Kinnear Detective Vogel Actor Matt Walsh Greg Pope Actor Michaela Watkins Louise Actor Mark Hamill Ted Actor Ryan Simpkins Aubrey Actor Jane Adams April Mitchum Actor Andy Samberg Eric Actor, Producer Kevin Costello Screenwriter Jorma Taccone Producer Akiva Schaffer Producer Will Allegra Producer Phil Lord Producer Christopher Miller Producer Billy Rosenberg Producer P. Jennifer Dana Producer, Executive Producer Al Di Producer Phil Hoelting Executive Producer Ross Jacobson Executive Producer Lian Hua Executive Producer Christian Sprenger Cinematographer Jacob Craycroft Film Editing David Wingo Original Music Brandon Tonner-Connolly Production Design Andy Eklund Art Director Cynthia A. Neibaur Set Decoration Sarah Mae Burton Costume Design Courtney Bright Casting Nicole Daniels Casting