Sam Pillsbury Director Kirsten Dunst Tina Spangler Actor Park Overall Evie Spangler Actor David Andrews Cal Spangler Actor Julia Whelan Rachel Spangler Actor Zachary Ray Sherman Adam Spangler Actor Margot Demeter Laurie Walsh Actor Karen Trumbo Jane Walsh Actor Daniel Kountz Ray Hood Actor Skylar Thiel-Klare Allison Wales Actor Karina Thiel-Klare Allison Wales Actor Art Burke Reverend Maclay Actor Angela Uherbelau Carmela Actor Kaci Baxter Holly Actor Jan Brehm Mrs. Crawley Actor Katie McClellan Girl Actor Kerry Evans Another Girl Actor John Kenower Youngest Inspector Actor Victor Morris Tom Actor Sherilyn Lawson Dr. Ross Actor Rebecca Nachison Mrs. Knapp Actor Tyler Gannon Melody Actor Katee Sackhoff Karen Gotatus Actor Marlyn Mason Grandma Spangler Actor Joe Ivy Dr. Warsaw Actor Raissa Flemming Birthing Coach Actor Meg Luckcuck Nurse Actor Karen Johnson-Miller Coach Mary Actor Jennifer McKechnie Anorexic Girl Actor Susan Cuscuna Screenwriter Diana Kerew Executive Producer James Bartle Cinematographer Michael S. Murphy Film Editing Stephen Edwards Original Music Bryan Ryman Production Design Sean Kennedy Set Decoration Rosalie Wallace Costume Design