Jul 30, 2014
"If I go insane, please don't put your wires in my brain." I figured Pink Floyd was the way to go, because, wow, this film is about as weird a piece of '60s counterculture as psychedelic folk and rock, and Pink Floyd's "If" came out in 1970. That's right, people, this film is that old, and if that's not enough for you, it's Malcolm McDowell's film debut, which I should tell you that he's always been into pushing boundaries when it comes to portraying kids as the creeps they truly are. Mind you, not every creepy kid acts on a school shooting or anything like that, but the fact of the mater is that I'm wondering if the sequel to this film is really "O Luck Man!", or "A Clockwork Orange". It's an understandable misconception, because, come on, let's face it, Lindsay Anderson's "Mick Travis" trilogy has to be respected for having the audacity to admit that Malcolm McDowell played the same character throughout the height of his career. Shoot, in that case, you can forget the "trilogy" title, because as many films as McDowell has been involved in that are shockingly similar to this one, we're looking at a bona fide "Mick Travis" franchise here (I'm sure the spin-off TV show would make HBO cringe), and it all started with this. I suppose this is a fair way to kick off the saga, although the film does seem to have a little trouble figuring out what it's doing at times.
I'm not saying that this artistic endeavor gets to be a little uneven with its style, but even its occasional alternations from a colored palette to black-and-white proves to be jarring, about as much as the more recurrent issue of thematic storytelling's either getting too direct to be subtle, or often getting too subtle for more over-the-top plotting touches to feel effective as satire, or fit into the more grounded aspects of the narrative. This film does not expend depth for the sake of thematic value as much as it perhaps could have, what with the generally solid characterization and acting, but a sense of humanity remains rather shaken by a satirical placement of style over substance that isn't even particularly even. Even greater unevenness rests in focus, as the film bloats itself with some subplots and branches that feel either a tad inconsequential or rather overblown, due to storytelling's finding difficulty in prioritizing the degree to which it focuses on its layers. Really, the structure of this plot is all sorts of overblown, as it's predominantly reliant on filler and meandering material to slowly, but surely unravel a narrative that just ends up coming out to be a whole lot of nothing, punctuated by bite. That's fine, I suppose, as there is enough color to storytelling to keep entertainment value adequate throughout overlong and meandering plotting, but things really start going downhill when that entertainment value lapses under dry spells, of which there are many to bland things up, and sometimes simply bore. At the very least, the cold direction further thins down resonance that is always challenged in this generally well-crafted, yet thoroughly flawed artistic effort. The final product is rather underwhelming, but it is indeed pretty enjoyable, challenging your patience, then securing it enough for you to embrace, if nothing else, the ideas behind this project.
A satirical study on youth's non-conformity's evolving into savage resistance against harsh peers and a questionable education system, this black comedy's plot concept is problematically driven by meanderings, yet still intriguingly worthy and chillingly daring, as well as surprisingly original, at least in its interpretation. Lindsay Anderson's direction intentionally carries a sort of distinctly British and abstractionist chill to its atmosphere that feels pretty limp, and does a lot to hold back the final product's engagement value, and yet, there's still something inspired about the directorial efforts here, for although style is even uneven, when it bites, it livens things up a considerable deal, while moments of realization to more subdued storytelling all but resonates. There's a certain entertainment value throughout this nonetheless often bland film, as there's almost always something for Anderson to soak up with his thoughtful storytelling and subtly sharp style, whose sense of nuance is aided by Anderson's work with a solid cast of talents. There's a certain lack of humanity in this film which is often too intensely focused up its stylistic and thematic value, so there's not much material for the performers to work with, but whether it be distinguished veterans or then-up-and-coming and now-distinguished young talents, most everyone delivers on pretty thorough charisma, if not more human layering than what is offered in David Sherwin's script. If this film has nothing else, it has an artistic confidence that is very charming, and sometimes about as effective as it can be in a film so slow and thin in focus, particularly within a script that, as irony would have it, is about as notable as any strengths, just as it is as notable as any flaw. For every misstep, Sherwin turns in a highlight, whether it be within a wit that, when backed by a realization in tone for this black comedy, amuses, sometimes outstandingly, or within offbeat characterization and set pieces that combine with an already thematically harrowing plot in order to bring the final product a uniqueness which makes the value of this effort a little easier to embrace. What keeps the final product from falling as memorable is largely thought-provoking themes, although the thematic value is not the only thing which holds your attention throughout a bland, but ultimately well-stylized and biting satire.
In the end, an uneven style at least keeps consistent in dehumanizing this character study, while focal unevenness derives from a defining structural dragging that is made all the more challenging by the directorial dull spells which render the final product underwhelming, but through generally confident direction, charismatic performances, and clever writing which does an adequate deal of justice to unique and daring subject matter, Lindsay Anderson's "if..." stands as a reasonably engaging and sometimes engrossing black comedy, despite its misguided spots.
2.5/5 - Fair
Verified