Edward Norton Father Brian Kilkenney Finn Director, Actor, Producer Ben Stiller Rabbi Jacob "Jake" Schram Actor Jenna Elfman Anna Riley Actor Anne Bancroft Ruth Schram Actor Eli Wallach Rabbi Lewis Actor Ron Rifkin Larry Friedman Actor Milos Forman Father Havel Actor Holland Taylor Bonnie Rose Actor Lisa Edelstein Ali Decker Actor Rena Sofer Rachel Rose Actor Ken Leung Don Actor Brian George Indian Bartender Actor Dagmara Domińczyk Claire Actor Kryss Anderson Craig Actor Stuart Blumberg Writer, Producer Gary Barber Executive Producer Roger Birnbaum Executive Producer Jonathan Glickman Executive Producer Hawk Koch Associate Producer Elmer Bernstein Original Music Anastas N. Michos Cinematographer Malcolm Campbell Film Editing Avy Kaufman Casting Wynn Thomas Production Design Chris Shriver Art Director Leslie E. Rollins Set Decoration Michael Kaplan Costume Design Victor DeNicola Key Hair Stylist Rita Ogden Makeup Artist Jackie Payne Hair Stylist Carla White Key Makeup Artist Jonathan Filley Production Manager Mark Cotone First Assistant Director