May 01, 2014
"National Lampoon's Thanksgiving Vacation"! Well, I don't suppose this film is all that Griswold, but, in all seriousness, it's hard to not think of that when looking at this film's premise, and the fact that John Hughes did, in fact, write the script for "National Lampoon's Vacation". Shoot, he wrote the short story upon which "Vacation" was based, and I know that's hard to believe, because as absurdist as "Vacation" is, it's hard to imagine that there was a point in which it was literature, but hey, at least it's a little less disconcerting than Hughes' certain April Fools' Day stories for "National Lampoon" magazine. Yeah, Hughes can get a little edgy with his "family" entertainment, or at least his material about family, but with this film, he cuts the whole family stuff out. I don't so much mean that this film is as edgy as Hughes' contributions to the "National Lampoon" franchise, as much as I mean that he really wanted to prove his diversity as a filmmaker by cutting all of that teen angst junk and making a film about men being men. Granted, he ended up making a film that leans closer to being about a manchild, but hey, that's to be expected when the slightly immature focus in question is played by a guy whose last name is Candy. Man, John Candy was awesome, and as this film reminds us, Steve Martin certainly knows how to pull his own, substantially lighter weight, but neither of them can completely carry the film away from its shortcomings.
With all my jokingly likening this to something along the lines of a "National Lampoon" flick of its '80s era, absurdity is limited, and that makes things all the more unnerving when the film's comedy does go a touch over the top, challenging the buyability of certain set pieces and plot points, while finding color contradicted by some subdued spots in pacing. Storytelling is plenty lively on the whole, but John Hughes' direction is often not especially brisk in its momentum, and when material to the scripting lapses, engagement value goes with it, as Hughes' almost dry storytelling, on its own, has trouble sustaining entertainment value and pacing. There's something kind of repetitious about Hughes' storytelling, and not just the directorial kind, as Hughes's script also gets to be a little driven by filler, to the point of losing focus that it probably can't afford to lose much of when looking at a runtime of merely over an hour-and-a-half. The film runs a brief, but repetitious course, giving you time to either lose investment or ponder upon how the course isn't even especially unique, as momentum goes further retarded by familiarity, and quite frankly, that's probably the worst thing than you can say about the final product. I suppose the pacing and believability problems are there, as surely as the also limited lapses in a sense of freshness, but they're barely worth complaining about when discussing a film that is generally so entertaining, so what ultimately holds the film back is simply its concept. Natural shortcomings to this fun, but inconsequential comedy opus overwhelm, and while I won't go so far as to say that the final product isn't entertaining enough to be memorable, it's not consistent, unique or intriguing enough to go all that far. Nevertheless, the film gets by as a classically enjoyable, if inconsequential comedy, with an adventurous side which goes sold by a good taste in, if nothing else, location.
Certainly, the filler-driven narrative would feel a little more dynamic if the locations were a little more dynamic, yet a sense of progression in the leads' sloppy adventure is sold by certain settings that feel distinguished enough to immerse you into the plot, which sustains enough of your attention on paper, that is, to a certain extent. What most holds back this film is its story's relative inconsequentiality, but to say that this isn't an interesting story is dishonest, because as a portrait on opposites struggling to get through a mutual conflict while their dynamics clash, it's thematically intriguing, and as a simple modern adventure narrative, it's lively, even in concept. As for the execution, John Hughes' direction is somewhat subdued in a manner which clashes with the lively writing and retards momentum, - though not as much as it does when it sees lapses in writing material - until the thoughtfulness goes accompanied by a celebration of Ira Newborn's upbeat score and Paul Hirsch's snappy editing that actually drives entertainment value. Yes, despite the aforementioned occasional slow spells, the film is not much if not entertaining, thanks to Hughes' direction, which, as I've said, needs colorful material in order to have its color thrive. This, of course, means that through all of the unevenness in believability and pacing, Hughes' script is colorful, with plenty of memorably clever lines, and even more genuinely memorable and endearing set pieces, backed by a colorful drawing of two distinguished leads, who go brought to life by their distinguished portrayers. The film is truly driven by the dynamic of Steve Martin and John Candy, who end up being the most consistent strength in the final product, with Martin's sometimes loopily dynamic portrayal of a grounded man who can't quite catch a break meeting Candy's trademark boisterous portrayal of a well-intentioned, but clumsy eccentric with an appealing contradiction that results in electric chemistry. Therein lies the real fun of this film, which doesn't offer much outside of fluff, but has enough memorable color on and off of the screen to endear, despite its shortcomings, both natural and consequential.
In conclusion, there are moments that are a little too absurdist and moments that are a little slow, all behind a narrative that is neither all that unique nor all that consequential, yet there also enough memorable locations and highlights in John Hughes' direction and writing, and enough dynamite charisma and chemistry between Steve Martin and John Candy to make "Planes, Trains & Automobiles" a thoroughly entertaining, if naturally lacking classic in buddy comedy adventure flicks.
2.5/5 - Fair
Verified