Stephen Bridgewater Director David Cass Sr. Director Kevin Sorbo Sheriff Preston Biggs Actor Jamie Anne Allman Olivia Thibodeaux Actor Lance Henriksen Monte James Actor Jillian Armenante Lettie Actor Dominique Swain Abigail Actor Felicia Day Blue Actor Lucy Lee Flippin Faith Actor Blake Gibbons Charlie Actor Don Swayze James Actor Richard Clarke Larsen Carson City Hotel Clerk Actor Silas Weir Mitchell Frank Actor Ken Magee Homer Actor E.E. Bell Luk Actor Chris McKenna Sheriff Logan Actor Steven H. Berman Screenwriter H. Daniel Gross Executive Producer Robert A. Halmi Executive Producer Larry Levinson Executive Producer Nick Lombardo Executive Producer Michael Moran Executive Producer Jeff Kloss Producer Lincoln Lageson Producer Joe Kraemer Original Music Al Lopez Cinematographer Jennifer Jean Cacavas Film Editing Penny Perry Casting Amy Beth Reece Casting Eugene Wyrick Production Design