Dallas Jenkins Director Judy Greer Grace Actor Pete Holmes Bob Actor Molly Belle Wright Beth Actor Lauren Graham Adult Beth Actor Beatrice Schneider Imogene Actor Matthew Lamb Claude Actor Essek Moore Ollie, Gladys, Ralph Actor, Actor, Actor Elizabeth Tabish Mrs. Grady Actor Kirk B.R. Woller Reverend Hopkins Actor Vanessa Benavente Teacher (1st Grade) Actor Stephanie Sy Mrs. Thomas Actor Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez Charlie Actor Ewan Matthys-Wood Leroy Actor Ryan Swanson Screenwriter Platte F. Clark Screenwriter Darin McDaniel Screenwriter, Producer Kevin Downes Producer Jon Erwin Producer Andrew Erwin Producer Chet Thomas Producer Daryl C. Lefever Producer K. Blaine Johnston Executive Producer Mark Kendell Executive Producer Gerald R. Molen Executive Producer Christopher Woodrow Executive Producer Tony Young Executive Producer C. Kim Miles Cinematographer John Quinn Film Editing Dan Haseltine Original Music Matthew S. Nelson Original Music Jean-Andre Carriere Production Design Maria Livingstone Costume Design Anthony J. Kraus Casting Jill Anthony Thomas Casting