Robert Redford Director, Producer James McAvoy Frederick Aiken Actor Robin Wright Mary Surratt Actor Kevin Kline Secretary Edwin M. Stanton Actor Evan Rachel Wood Anna Surratt Actor Danny Huston Joseph Holt Actor Tom Wilkinson Reverdy Johnson Actor Alexis Bledel Sarah Actor Justin Long Nicholas Baker Actor Colm Meaney Gen. David Hunter Actor James Badge Dale William Hamilton Actor Johnny Simmons John Surratt Actor Toby Kebbell John Wilkes Booth Actor Jonathan Groff Louis Weichman Actor Stephen Root John Lloyd Actor James D. Solomon Screenwriter Greg Shapiro Producer Bill Holderman Producer Brian Falk Producer Robert Stone Producer Joe Ricketts Executive Producer Jeremiah Samuels Executive Producer Webster Stone Executive Producer Newton Thomas Sigel Cinematographer Kalina Ivanov Production Design Craig McKay Film Editing Louise Frogley Costume Design Mark Isham Original Music Avy Kaufman Casting Melissa Levander Set Decoration