Zach Braff Aidan Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer Kate Hudson Sarah Actor Mandy Patinkin Gabe Actor Josh Gad Noah Actor Joey King Grace Actor Pierce Gagnon Tucker Actor Donald Faison Anthony Actor Ashley Greene Janine Actor Jim Parsons Paul Actor Michael Weston Jerry Actor Alexander Chaplin Rabbi Rosenberg Actor Allan Rich Rabbi Twersky Actor Cody Sullivan Jesse Actor Silvia Curiel Esperanza Actor Nichole Galicia Juliet Actor Max Wright Actor Adam Braff Screenwriter, Producer Stacey Sher Producer Michael Shamberg Producer Christopher Woodrow Executive Producer Molly Conners Executive Producer Maria Cestone Executive Producer Sarah E. Johnson Executive Producer Hoyt David Morgan Executive Producer Lawrence Sher Cinematographer Myron I. Kerstein Film Editing Rob Simonsen Original Music Tony Fanning Production Design Beth Wooke Set Decoration Avy Kaufman Casting Betsy Heimann Costume Design