Daniel Ezra Spencer James Actor Taye Diggs Coach Billy Baker Actor Samantha Logan Olivia Baker Actor Bre-Z Tiana Cooper Actor Greta Onieogou Layla Faisal Actor Monet Mazur Laura Fine-Baker Actor Michael Evans Behling Jordan Baker Actor Cody Christian Asher Actor Karimah Westbrook Grace James Actor Jalyn Hall Dillon James Actor Chelsea Tavares Patience Actor GeffriMaya Simone Guest Star Kelly Jenrette Amara Guest Star Peyton "Alex" Smith Damon Guest Star April Blair Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Rob Hardy Executive Producer Michael Schultz Director Nkechi Okoro Carroll Writer