Abigail Heringer Contestant Lance Bass Host Brendan Morais Contestant Deandra Kanu Contestant Ivan Hall Contestant Jessenia Cruz Contestant Joe Amabile Contestant Karl Smith Contestant Kelsey Weier Contestant Kenny Braasch Contestant Mari Pepin-Solis Contestant Maurissa Gunn Contestant Natasha Parker Contestant Noah Erb Contestant Serena Chew Contestant Serena Pitt Contestant Tahzjuan Hawkins Contestant Tammy Ly Contestant Victoria Larson Contestant Victoria Paul Contestant Mike Fleiss Executive Producer Martin Hilton Executive Producer Nicole Woods Executive Producer Elan Gale Executive Producer