Jesse Palmer Host Alexe-Anne "Alexe" Godin Contestant Bailey Brown Contestant Brian Autz Contestant Dale Moss Contestant Hakeem Moulton Contestant Jeremy Simon Contestant Jessica "Jess" Edwards Contestant Jonathon Johnson Contestant Justin Glaze Contestant Katherine "Kat" Izzo Contestant Kyle Howard Contestant Lexi Young Contestant Riquerdy "Ricky" Marinez Contestant Sam McKinney Contestant Spencer Conley Contestant Zoe McGrady Contestant April Kirkwood Contestant Charles "CK" King Contestant Jack Lencioni Contestant Kathy Swarts Contestant Keith Gordon Contestant Kim Buike Contestant Leslie Fhima Contestant Natascha Hardee Contestant Ralph "RJ" Johnson Contestant Mike Fleiss Executive Producer Martin Hilton Executive Producer Nicole Woods Executive Producer Tim Warner Executive Producer Louis Caric Executive Producer Peter Geist Executive Producer