Ashley Graham Host Jonathan Adler Judge Tiffany Brooks Judge James Bender Self Michel Smith Boyd Self Keith Bynum Self Kristina Crestin Self Anthony Elle Self Christina Haack Self Mike Jackson Self Brian Kleinschmidt Self Mika Kleinschmidt Self Jonathan Knight Self Antonia Lofaso Self Ty Pennington Self Jasmine Roth Self Egypt Sherrod Self Evan Thomas Self Alison Victoria Self Fred Soulie Executive Producer Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Phil Breman Executive Producer Patrick Byrnes Executive Producer Rebecca D. Miller Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer