Kristen Wiig Jenny Hart, MayKay Bueller Voice, Executive Producer Maya Rudolph Betty Hart, Norma Voice Jillian Bell Violet Hart, Cherish Voice Ike Barinholtz Wayne Edwards Voice Kumail Nanjiani Jesus Voice Fortune Feimster Brenda Guest Voice Emily Spivey Louise Guest Voice, Executive Producer Mary Steenburgen Crystalynn Poole Guest Voice Oscar Montoya David Guest Voice Jeremy Rowley Mayor Webb, Jimmy Lee Guest Voice Drew Tarver Randy, Charles Lee Guest Voice Andy Bobrow Bud, Dustin Guest Voice Christy Stratton-Mann Dawn Guest Voice Chris Parnell Ian David Cole Guest Voice Rich Blomquist Brandon Guest Voice Phil Lord Executive Producer Christopher Miller Executive Producer Seth Cohen Executive Producer