Sutton Foster Michelle Simms Actor Kaitlyn Jenkins Boo Actor Julia Goldani Telles Sasha Actor Bailey Buntain Ginny Actor Emma Dumont Melanie Actor Kelly Bishop Fanny Guest Star Hunter Foster Scotty Guest Star Stacey Oristano Truly Stone Guest Star Liza Weil Milly Stone Guest Star Nathan Parsons Godot Guest Star Seth Rudetsky Seth Guest Star Jeanine Mason Cozette Guest Star Michelle Elkin Dance Captain Guest Star Garrett Coffey Roman Guest Star Carlton Wilborn Choreographer Guest Star Amy Sherman-Palladino Executive Producer, Director, Writer