Andie MacDowell Judge Olivia Lockhart Actor Dylan Neal Jack Griffith Actor Bruce Boxleitner Bob Beldon Actor Barbara Niven Peggy Beldon Actor Brennan Elliott Warren Saget Actor Teryl Rothery Grace Sherman Actor Sarah Smyth Justine Actor Paula Shaw Charlotte Jeffers Actor Corey Sevier Seth Gunderson Actor Timothy Webber Moon Actor Elyse Levesque Maryellen Sherman Actor Sebastian Spence Cliff harting Actor Garry Chalk Sheriff Troy Davis Actor Charlie Carrick John Bowman Actor Claude Duhamel Fisherman Guest Star Beverley Elliott Ruthie Guest Star Dan Wigutow Executive Producer Michael M. Scott Director Caroline Moore Executive Producer Allen Lewis Executive Producer Debbie Macomber Executive Producer Harvey Kahn Executive Producer Bruce Graham Writer