Italia Ricci April Carver Actor Mary Page Keller Sara Carver Actor Aisha Dee Beth Kingston Actor Richard Brancatisano Dominic Actor Haley Ramm Brenna Carver Actor Scott Michael Foster Leo Hendrie Actor Jessica Meraz Natalie Guest Star Abhi Sinha Danny Guest Star Parker Mack Finn Madill Guest Star Krysta Rodriguez Vanessa Guest Star Colin Egglesfield Dr. Barratt Guest Star Steven Weber Dr. George Carver Guest Star Michael Hyland Chris Guest Star Alycia Grant Meg Guest Star Robbie Amell Ecstasy Man Guest Star Patrick Sean Smith Executive Producer Susanna Fogel Executive Producer Joni Lefkowitz Executive Producer Aaron Kaplan Executive Producer Jeanne Leitenberg Writer Joe Lazarov Director