Kiernan Shipka Sabrina Spellman Actor Miranda Otto Zelda Spellman Actor Lucy Davis Hilda Spellman Actor Ross Lynch Harvey Kinkle Actor Michelle Gomez Mary Wardwell, Madam Satan Actor Chance Perdomo Ambrose Spellman Actor Jaz Sinclair Rosalind Walker Actor Richard Coyle Father Blackwood Actor Tati Gabrielle Prudence Actor Adeline Rudolph Agatha Actor Abigail Cowen Dorcas Actor Lachlan Watson Susie Putnam Actor Bronson Pinchot George Hawthorne Actor Gavin Leatherwood Nicholas Scratch Actor Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Jon Goldwater Executive Producer Lee Toland Krieger Executive Producer