Peter Krause Nick George Actor Donald Sutherland Tripp Darling Actor William Baldwin Patrick Darling Actor Natalie Zea Karen Darling Actor Glenn Fitzgerald Rev. Brian Darling Actor Samaire Armstrong Juliet Darling Actor Seth Gabel Jeremy Darling Actor Zoe McLellan Lisa George Actor Jill Clayburgh Letitia Darling Actor Blair Underwood Simon Elder Actor Daniel Cosgrove Freddy Mason Guest Star Bellamy Young Ellen Darling Guest Star Chloë Grace Moretz Kiki George Guest Star Laura Margolis Daisy Guest Star Amara Zaragoza Natalie Kimpton Actor Will Shadley Brian Darling Jr. Guest Star Shawn Michael Patrick Clark the Chauffeur Guest Star Candis Cayne Carmelita Guest Star Michelle Krusiec Mei Ling Hwa Darling Guest Star Zoey Botnick Leah Darling Guest Star Craig Wright Executive Producer, Writer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Josh Reims Executive Producer, Writer Matthew Gross Executive Producer Bryan Singer Executive Producer Yahlin Chang Writer Peter Elkoff Writer Christopher Landon Writer Jessica Brickman Writer Jake Coburn Writer Jack Bender Director Tad Quill Writer Nancy Won Writer Joey Soloway Writer Michael Schultz Director David Petrarca Director Michael Grossman Director Jamie Babitt Director