Jonny Lee Miller Eli Stone Actor Victor Garber Jordan Wethersby Actor Natasha Henstridge Taylor Wethersby Actor Loretta Devine Patti Actor Sam Jaeger Matt Dowd Actor James Saito Dr. Chen Actor Matt Letscher Nathan Stone Actor Julie Gonzalo Maggie Dekker Actor Tom Amandes M'artin Posner Guest Star Yvonne Delarosa Blanca Ramirez Guest Star Jos Viramontes Oscar Ramirez Guest Star Mark Harelik Attorney Guest Star Lorna Raver Judge Gilberg Guest Star Robin Gammell Judge Guest Star Dave Engfer Eager Associate Guest Star Keely Watson Delivery Guy Guest Star Ossie Mair Customs Official Guest Star Barry Livingston ICE Attorney Guest Star Cheryl Carter Jury Forewoman Guest Star William Behlendorf Choir singer Guest Star Tim Davis Singing Lawyer Guest Star Beth Geiger Acupuncture Patient Guest Star Marc Guggenheim Writer Greg Berlanti Writer Michael Schultz Director