Jonny Lee Miller Eli Stone Actor Victor Garber Jordan Wethersby Actor Natasha Henstridge Taylor Wethersby Actor Loretta Devine Patti Actor Sam Jaeger Matt Dowd Actor James Saito Dr. Chen Actor Matt Letscher Nathan Stone Actor Julie Gonzalo Maggie Dekker Actor Jason George Keith Bennett Actor Bridget Moynahan Ashley Cardiff Guest Star Laura Benanti Beth Keller Guest Star Debrah Farentino Ellen Wethersby Guest Star Melinda Clarke Dr. Lee Guest Star Jonathan Banks Agent Jonathan Maine Guest Star Philip Anthony-Rodriguez Michael Pelfrey Guest Star Michael Silver Elliott Russell Guest Star Richard Gant Judge Marlon Anderson Guest Star Jonathan McMurtry Shop Owner Guest Star George Murdock Future Wallender Guest Star Victor McCay Irving Wallender Guest Star Danielle Panabaker Genny Clarke Guest Star Ron Underwood Director Leila Gerstein Writer