Alicia Sanchez Contestant Aarti Sequeira Guest Chris Nirschel Contestant Howie Drummond Contestant Jeff Mauro Contestant Juba Kali Contestant Justin Balmes Contestant Justin Davis Contestant Jyll Everman Contestant Katy Clark Contestant Mary Beth Albright Contestant Orchid Paulmeier Contestant Penny Davidi Contestant Susie Jimenez Contestant Vic Moea Contestant Whitney Chen Contestant Bobby Flay Judge Bob Tuschman Judge Susie Fogelson Judge Giada De Laurentiis Judge Donna Macletchie Executive Producer