Mark Little Gary Creator, Voice, Director, Writer Kyle Dooley Hanley Voice James Hartnett Jeff Voice Alexander Conti Taylor Voice David Berni Steve Voice Emma Hunter Teacher, Student, Bloody Mary Voice Tim Gilbert Grundleman Voice Sara Garcia Michaela Voice Marito Lopez Marito Voice Kayla Lorette Leslie Voice Julie Lemieux Succubus Voice Brandon Hackett Demon in Bar Voice Miguel Rivas Gordon Voice Becky Johnson Monk Voice Chris Wilson Fleshler Voice Paloma Nunez Judy Voice Ana Sana Simone Voice Jonathan Sconza Curtis Voice Ron Pardo Dad Voice Stephanie Tolev Steph Voice Lou Solis Director Stephanie Kaliner Writer Mark Satterthwaite Writer Joshua Bowen Executive Producer Pia Chikiamco Executive Producer Brendan Burch Producer