Lea Michele Rachel Berry Actor Matthew Morrison Will Schuester Actor Jane Lynch Sue Sylvester Actor Naya Rivera Santana Lopez Actor Chris Colfer Kurt Hummel Actor Amber Riley Mercedes Jones Actor Darren Criss Blaine Anderson Actor Chord Overstreet Sam Evans Actor Lauren Potter Becky Jackson Actor Michael Lerner Sidney Greene Guest Star Max Adler Dave Karofsky Guest Star Josh Sussman Jacob Ben Israel Guest Star Bill A. Jones Rod Remington Guest Star Earlene Davis Andrea Carmichael Guest Star Chad James Buchanan Bartender Guest Star Rod McLachlan Newsstand Guy Guest Star Cyrina Fiallo Web Critic Guest Star Tony Colitti Salvatore Guest Star John Ainsworth Barclay Guest Star Shaun J. Brown Theatre Patron Guest Star Jeff Doucette NY Times Critic Guest Star Ryan Murphy Executive Producer Brad Falchuk Executive Producer Dante Di Loreto Executive Producer