Christina Hendricks Beth Boland Actor Lidya Jewett Sara Hill Actor Matthew Lillard Dean Boland Actor Manny Montana Rio Actor Retta Ruby Hill Actor Mae Whitman Annie Marks Actor Reno Wilson Stan Hill Actor John Gloria Luke, Folksy Cop Guest Star Jonathan Silverman Dave Guest Star Lauren Lapkus Phoebe Guest Star Scarlett Abinante Emma Guest Star Noureen DeWulf Krystal Guest Star Antonimar Murphy Mercedes Guest Star Michael Weaver Director Jenna Bans Screenwriter, Executive Producer Dean Parisot Executive Producer Jeannine Renshaw Executive Producer Mark Wilding Executive Producer Eric Tignini Director Samantha Taylor Pickett Writer Steven Rubinshteyn Writer